Case Files · How to Play

How a case plays

One person hosts. Everyone else is a detective. You work the evidence segment by segment, then hand the District Attorney a case file. She decides if it holds up.

No spoilers on this page. It works for every case.

Two ways to play

At home

One person hosts and keeps the Host Guide private. Everyone else plays together as one team, with the exhibits printed or on a shared screen. Great for game night, a party, or family.

On stream

The host runs the case on YouTube, Twitch, or anywhere else, with on-camera guests, chat, or both. At each break, chat votes with your platform's own poll tools. Streaming and monetizing your playthrough is allowed.

Every game needs a host. There's no solo mode, because the host is the one who knows the answer.

What you need

1
A host

Reads the start of the Host Guide and the solution before game night, then runs the show.

2+
Detectives

Any size team, or a whole chat. Everyone works the same case together.

TV
A screen

A TV, monitor, or stream for the screen graphics. Text is large enough to read across a room or on a 1080p stream.

✎
Pens & a printer

Optional but nice: print the exhibits, the players' DA Case File form, and the host's score sheet.

The flow of a case

1 · The briefing

Each segment opens with the host reading the briefing while the numbered screen graphics tell the story. Nobody stares at a blank screen.

2 · New evidence

The host releases that segment's exhibits: reports, interviews, records, photos. Every exhibit has a number (E-01, E-02...). Not all of it matters, and some of it points the wrong way.

3 · The break

Talk it out. Note which exhibits you're leaning toward and who you suspect. On stream, chat votes. Then on to the next segment.

Bigger cases run five segments and take one or two game nights. The Host Guide marks good stopping points if you want to split it, and your notes and score carry over.

Building the DA's case file

In the last segment, the District Attorney sends a memo: she only has a jury's attention for so long. Bring her your best exhibits, the ones that prove it, and not everything you found. Each case prints its exhibit limit on the memo and on your form (Billable Hours allows twelve).

A strong file proves what a jury needs to believe, such as how the victim died, who had the chance, and why. Any exhibit that proves a point counts, so there's more than one right way to build it. Padding the file with junk or misleading evidence weakens it.

Then your team makes the big call:

Submit for review

Hand over the evidence and let the DA draw the conclusion. The safe play.

Recommend charges

Put your names on it. Name the suspect and the charge. Bigger reward, bigger risk.

How the DA decides

Your fileYour callWhat happens
StrongRecommend charges, right suspectCharges Filed: Commendation. The best ending.
StrongSubmit for reviewCharges Filed. A win, but no commendation.
StrongRecommend charges, wrong suspectSent Back. The DA catches the mismatch. One more try.
WeakSubmit for reviewSent Back. Fix the file. One more try.
WeakRecommend chargesBack to Traffic Duty. Even the right name doesn't hold up without the evidence. The killer walks.

On a second try you can only submit for review, so no guessing a new name. Every ending has its own script and screen graphic, followed by the full solution walkthrough.

Hints and points

Hints

The host holds three hint cards for each segment. You have to ask. The host never offers one.

  • Nudge points at where to look (−2)
  • Pointer names the exhibit that matters (−4)
  • Spell It Out says what it proves (−6)

Hints never name the killer and never tell you which exhibits are junk. They cost points but don't change the DA's decision.

Points (bragging rights)

The DA's decision is the real result. Points are for comparing groups or streamers.

  • Strong evidence earns points, junk and misleading picks lose them
  • Bonus for recommending the right suspect and charge
  • Penalty for getting sent back, and for each hint

The full scoring is on the host's score sheet.

Tips for the host

  • Read the "Welcome, Host" page, Part 1, and the solution before game night. Keep the Host Guide off screen and away from players.
  • Click through each segment's screen graphics once so you know the cues.
  • Keep a poker face: read the scripted lines, don't react to theories, and give every suspect the same tone.
  • When players ask a factual question, point them to an exhibit instead of answering.
  • Streaming? The PNG packs drop every graphic into OBS or your streaming software at 1920×1080.
Try it free

Play Segment 1 of Billable Hours free before you buy, or browse all Case Files.

One purchase covers your household or your stream. Rated 16+, non-graphic.

All characters, places, agencies, and events in Case Files are fictional. Any resemblance to real people or businesses is coincidental.